| Song reviews |
|---|
05-02-2005 16:44 CMMLover04 |
52 posts
|
rhythm 
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
 I absolutely adore this song!! When I first got Kelly's CD, thats one of the songs I played over and over again!  This song is awesome! Way to go, Kelly! |
| 06-02-2005 02:51 Because_Of_U |
52 posts
| haha me too! i play this song on repeat every nite when i go to bed....  |
| 06-02-2005 10:28 evtblpfan |
1 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
I'm with XxEvGrlyxX...she's right.
Kelly Clarkson got SAVED by Ben Moody and Mr. David Hodges...their grammy winning song-writing skills saved Kelly from the fate of many pop artists.
I mean Kelly is talented and all, but lets give props to Ben and David on this song and Addicted...the two songs are the greatest songs on the album and we all know why.
|
| 06-02-2005 20:34 Because_Of_U |
52 posts
| "Kelly Clarkson got SAVED by Ben Moody and Mr. David Hodges...their grammy winning song-writing skills saved Kelly from the fate of many pop artists." <
|
| 06-02-2005 21:55 XxEvGrlyxX |
18 posts
| hell yea evtblpfan at least some one knows smthn and becauseofyou or wutever ur name iz if u fuckin see wut i write i did say they HELPED but that fuckin means that kelly clarkson CO wrote it too god juss dont say nethin at all cause u makin urself sound stupid ok god makin me sound like a kelly clarkson hater and fuck i AM a kelly clarkson fan and if ne one wanna believe different u obviously dont know me |
| 06-02-2005 21:57 ellessilver |
2,223 posts
|
rhythm 
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
Just finished listening to it...  |
| 06-02-2005 21:57 XxEvGrlyxX |
18 posts
| wtf why did u copy wut evtblpfan wrote god cant think of nethin to say..............yea u know itz true |
| 07-02-2005 01:42 Because_Of_U |
52 posts
| ACTUALLY...if u didnt notice there was an arrow symbol after wut i quoted which means that i wrote something after that...this is wut it should have sed... "Kelly Clarkson got SAVED by Ben Moody and Mr. David Hodges...their grammy winning song-writing skills saved Kelly from the fate of many pop artists." Kelly didnt get "saved" by anyone. She writes her own music, ben and david 'helped' her write it. THEY are the ones who CO-WROTE it i guess u can say. Kelly actually WROTE it HERSELF, they just "touched it up" thats all.
and just so ya kno, im not sayin ur a kelly hater, im not tryin to sound like a bitch with my replies so u dont need to be gettin a nasty n shit to me. it just seems as if ur giving david and ben ALL the credit for these two songs, and they dont deserve all the credit. kelly deserves most of it, she did most of the writing, not the guys. they play the melody and its awsome, thats wut i give them credit for. its good that ur a kelly fan, im glad. n no, i dont KNO u, n u dont kno me, the only point i was tryin to get across was that she wrote this song wayyy before she even met those guys, so she was actually the one who WROTE the song, they just "touched it up" with her. geeze. |
| 07-02-2005 03:20 XxEvGrlyxX |
18 posts
| ok thiz iz wut im tryin to get across iz that they all deserve the same credit b/c they all did there part so dont be sayin kelly clarkson should get most of it b/c im sure david and ben wrote the muzik and part of the lyrics so yea and wen i first posted i wuz talkin to everyone who wuz sayin kelly did a good job on the song b/c she wasnt the only one writin it and yes they did save her from not having these 2 songs on the album b/c if they werent there addicted probaly wouldnt have been wrote and thiz song probaly wouldnt be as awsum as it iz |
| 07-02-2005 03:38 Because_Of_U |
52 posts
| ok...well it just seemed as if u were givin all the credit to ben and david. thats all. n thats y i posted her comments about her songs on here so u can see that they didnt deserve most of the credit. also, im sure addicted would have been on the cd, cuz again, she wrote that even before she met ben and david. but i do agree wit u on one thing, that the songs prolly would sound as great Instrument Wise bc ben and david are extremely great musicians. |
| 07-02-2005 03:44 Because_Of_U |
52 posts
| i meant to say *wouldnt* |
| 07-02-2005 04:28 simpleplanfan05 |
18 posts
| sure addicted would have been on the cd but it wouldnt have been as good and im not saying intrument wise but i mean the lyrics wouldnt have been as powerful without ben and davids help so i agree with evgrly |
| 07-02-2005 05:01 Because_Of_U |
52 posts
| i disagree... i think the lyrics would have been just as good as they are now. Kelly is a great writer... she can write really amazing songs, just like the ones on her cd. she writes all the time about everything, so i think that it would still be a great song if she didnt have their help to "patch it up"  |
| 07-02-2005 23:06 simpleplanfan05 |
18 posts
| actually the lyrics would be different if she didnt have ben and david to help why do you think everybody likes those two songs because there different then the rest because they helped DUH!!!!!!!!!! |
| 08-02-2005 02:19 Because_Of_U |
52 posts
| i dunno, i liked those two songs the first time i heard them and i didnt even kno that they helped her with them til like a few days after i got the album. My favorite was Because of You, but I liked Hear Me and Where is Your Heart better than Addicted, but then Addicted grew on me. actually its not just because david and ben helped Kelly with these two songs that everyone loves them so much, its Kellys ORIGIONAL lyrics AND the guys' help with these songs. Im sure that MOST fans like these songs because of the lyrics (that are SO deep and meaningful) and the melody (which the guys play) Half the fans prolly just thought that ben and david only played the melody and didnt help her with the lyrics at first. I definately give these guys credit for their great job with the help of these songs, dont get me wrong. but there are things that i do disagree with yall on about it. but heyy, everyones entitled to their opinions. |
| 08-02-2005 04:14 simpleplanfan05 |
18 posts
| you spelt original wrong but i still think those two songs stuck out because they are different and are deeper than the others more like evanesence songs and its obvious why because ben and david did help with lyrics and music |
| 13-02-2005 04:52 XxEvGrlyxX |
18 posts
| i agree wit simpleplanfan b/c it iz of ben and david that these songs r more deeper then the rest itz not juss b/c of coincidence b/c the way it wuz written wuz deep like evanescence songs so0o0 once again the two guyz achieve at writing an awsum song!!!!!!!! |
| 14-02-2005 04:57 XOLuvMeFerMeOX |
36 posts
| s0o0o0 once again, the guys arent the only ones who wrote the songs.... Kelly DID write it too... dont give all the credit to the guys.... thats all im tryin to say.... |
| 14-02-2005 08:09 XxEvGrlyxX |
18 posts
| ok im gonna say thiz AGAIN im not givin the guyz ALL the credit im givin them the same amount of credit as i give kelly and that iz wut i have been sayin the whole time |
| 14-02-2005 23:31 simpleplanfan05 |
18 posts
| okay thats whut evgrly has been saying all along and thats the same thing ive been saying we havent been saying that the guys did everything because we know kelly did some of the song too |
| 17-02-2005 03:15 XOLuvMeFerMeOX |
36 posts
| AGAIN...im not sayin that thats not wut ur sayin, im sayin that it SEEMS like yall r givin the guys all the credit, just by sayin that the songs wouldnt be as good if they didnt help her.... to me, i think theyd be just as good. the guys do the intrumental parts, yea, they did help write the song, but their best talent is with musical instruments, n thats y the songs have such an amazing beat to them, bc the guys played.
just to let yall kno, im not tryin to make myself seem liek a bitch, but all i was tryin to say was that yall seemed liek yall was givin the guys all the credit, n only givin kelly some of it, when she was the one who actually wrote the entire song before she even met the guys. they collaberated with her to help her reword some of it basically, n then to play the rhythm n beats... |
| 06-03-2005 21:24 VoicexInside |
1 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
 This is one my favorite songs!! Ijust love the way Kelly Clarkson expresses the song...like how she raises her voice *sigh*...  |
| 20-03-2005 07:10 pinkybabe |
290 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
I cried the frist time I really listened to this song. It's an AMAZING song! Just amazing! |
| 29-03-2005 13:51 monkeypie66 |
7 posts
|
rhythm 
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
Great song! Love it!  |
| 10-04-2005 13:29 musicmyantidrug |
13 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
This is one of my favourite songs on the album. It's so beautiful. |
8.5
video corrected on 27-04-2009
Send "Because Of You" ringtones to your cell