| Song reviews |
|---|
25-04-2004 12:09 ignacio |
 14,843 posts
| Good song |
25-04-2004 12:12 ForeverFalling |
 4,923 posts
| tehehe James
i thought it was a good song too |
29-06-2004 23:40 DaRkMaGiK |
 8 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
nice country song !?
not bad.. but not good..
fun to play ! |
23-07-2004 03:19 myothername |
 43 posts
| yeah... this song is bit too much on the country side for me! |
04-09-2004 07:30 ChokoFant |
 58 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
This Song Rocks |
06-09-2004 13:25 Scar Tissue |
 3 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
a really good song...which is good for singing with James ...!
and i love itttttttttt
|
18-10-2004 20:01 fadetoblack134 |
 23 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
James's voice sounds really good in it.
Gave me a fright when I first heard it "Metallica, country?!", but it's grown on me, definitely. Love it now.  |
27-10-2004 01:15 dannyramone |
 37 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
It's a great song, has a definite country feel to it..
In fact, it's more country than almost everything country radio plays today, and it's METALLICA! But it also has a metallica feel to it, it 's a kick ass! |
08-12-2004 01:32 mbloom |

 7 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
This is the best Metallica´s song !!!! |
29-12-2004 11:58 TypeXNEMESIS |
 104 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
its ok
at least it shows that metallica can excel in all styles including......COUNTRY?
unpredictable |
22-01-2005 00:37 MEade |
 224 posts
| i like this song, it reminds me to my grandmother  |
22-01-2005 01:58 zoejanes |
 45 posts
| one of the hardest song of metallica  |
06-02-2005 21:09 Jehryni |
 86 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
This song is supposedly about his mom, and how he never paid much attention to her until it was too late...lol...anyway
I like this song--its proof that Metallica can excel at anything--next up
Raptallica! |
19-04-2005 01:42 NoLeafCloverXZ |
 72 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
i hope you are joking zoe janes...
good song but the video kind of sucked...james was like 100% of the video until kirk lars n jason walked passed a car and looked into the window...and that was kind of if it for them |
22-04-2005 18:03 mexican_gorilla |
 11 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
well yeah the video is almost 100% james cause the song is about his mom you know. so not to sound so much of a kiss ass here but i have been going through some of the same things with my mom and the video kinda goes with the whole song vibe. it might not be the most interesting or entertainning video but it goes with the song. |
12-05-2005 19:56 hockeygoalie |
 232 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
this is a great song! cool rythm too |
03-06-2005 22:39 badekake |
 25 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
beautiful song.. beautiful. |
11-06-2005 16:46 Blackbeard |
 59 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
a beutiful song |
16-07-2005 07:30 BillyHeadBanger |
 44 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
The greatest of ANY acoustic songs ive ever heard. This and stairway to heaven are the only 2 things in the world that can make me cry(with respect)
God Bless Metallica!  |
14-12-2005 19:12 Vinnie_King |
 19 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
Oh, come on people... This is NOT country. It takes more than a steel pedal to make a country song. This is more folk-sy. And it kicks major ass. |
21-12-2005 20:58 MKK_girl |
 236 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
This song is so... unbeliveble
Makes me wanna cry...
And the video dosen't suck (what? I like james ) |
24-02-2006 16:55 Monkeynut |
 3 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
This song rocks. I luv the lyrics
the video is crap though. James sounds awesome in this song his voice is the best when he recorded this song.
Lars rulz he is my idol as a drummer
Metallica rock  |
17-09-2006 20:07 Hurricane_07 |
 3 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
This song literally saved my life. I was sitting at the edge of a bridge with my tiny MP3-player about to jump down in the great darkness. Why? My mom was (still is actually) an alcoholic...
In this moment, this song started. I listened to the words, and I suddenly changed my mind and decided to give my mom one last chance. And here I am, happier than ever!
Metallica saved my life literally! I ow them alot! |
14-12-2006 20:44 galron995 |
 13 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
there are only 2 songs that made me tear: this one and "and sadness will sear" by trivium. its a great song. goes right to the stomach...  |
08-04-2007 13:05 metallicaF |
 31 posts
|
rhythm 
melody 
instruments 
lyrics 
vocal 
never i ask of you but never i gave...gr8 |