Pink Floyd - Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I-V) Reviews

Song details
Title	Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I-V)
Artist	Pink Floyd
Album	Wish You Were Here (1975) , Track 1 , A Collection Of Great Dance Songs (1981) , Track 4 , Delicate Sound Of Thunder (1988) , Track 1 , Pulse (1995) , Track 1

Song score
Rhythm	: 9.6
Melody	: 9.4
Instruments	: 9.7
Lyrics	: 9.8
Vocal	: 9.9
This song has been reviewed 18 times. Overall score for this song, 9.7.

Showing reactions 1-25 of 28

Page 1 of 2

Select page : [1] 2 next »

add review Song reviews
0 @ 08-11-2004 18:46 llllll_R_llllll
14 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal I agree whit you that song is the best pink floyd song when i listen to it i have a special feeling inside me
0 @ 08-11-2004 18:47 llllll_R_llllll
14 posts	:_ :_
0 @ 08-11-2004 18:49 llllll_R_llllll
14 posts	_: _ :_ _ :_
0 @ 15-07-2005 16:28 podjo
494 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal dude,don't put all those smilies,I almost got banned for that once.
0 @ 27-07-2005 13:23 Rockaway
30 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal imnot trying to offend anyone by saying this cuz i know there are some die hard fans out there, and i am one, just not for this band(LedZep). Roger Waters has an amazing voice WHEN HE SINGS. But he barely sings and this song is a perfect example. this and many other pf songs put me to sleep.
0 @ 16-08-2005 14:20 Rockaway
30 posts	Sorry people my freind was on my sn and wrote this. Pink Floyd rocks hard!
0 @ 11-11-2005 01:41 Molle_Rulz
223 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal Awesome. Sits you on your arse and makes you listen. I played this for one of my classes once and they couldn't help themselves. They all started swaying. Listen to this song in a dark room, looking into a candle flame. It's the trippiest feeling I've ever got. This song sends chills up my spine. It's so haunting and yet strangely positive for Pink Floyd. Molle
0 @ 12-12-2005 22:07 Fndr
62 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal Great song
0 @ 01-01-2006 08:50 Unforgiven2
53 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal This is a tribute to Syd Barrett, an original member of Pink Floyd . He was their lead guitarist and wrote most of their early hits, but he went crazy from taking to much LSD and was kicked out of the band. So anyway he wrote their songs while he was stoned or trippin so thats why thay are so Phsycidallic and random.
0 @ 07-01-2006 17:43 Durangoo
32 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal hey! don't talk bad about Pink Floyd :@ ! PINK FLOYD ! ! !
0 @ 08-01-2006 04:05 Unforgiven2
53 posts	whos saying anything bad
0 @ 09-01-2006 23:44 jimbo_johnny
1 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal Interesting that a Pink Floyd discussion has sprouted so recently. I think Dark Side and Wish You Were Here, as well as some other music from different bands is the only thing keeping me going. Glad to know some other people are similarly touched by Floyd, easily in the top 5 of rock's greatest, if not the best.
0 @ 19-04-2006 02:48 Fndr
62 posts	bloody awsome, excellent song, jeez, i love it
0 @ 15-07-2006 02:09 onepillmakesyou
3 posts	Shine on, you crazy diamond. <3 R.I.P Syd Barrett
0 @ 15-07-2006 02:10 onepillmakesyou
3 posts	Shine on, you crazy diamond. <3 R.I.P Syd Barrett
0 @ 15-07-2006 20:19 PinkFloyd
25,917 posts	so amazing and beautiful, great, GREAT piece of work
0 @ 24-07-2006 15:20 cjt17
12 posts	To Syd Barrett, to whom without, would not have created one of history's greatest band. This song is a touching memoir of his great and beautifull legacy. May he rest in peace. I salute you Mr. Barrett.
0 @ 24-10-2006 02:16 darkangelous6
1 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal dude, when i listen to that song i just throw anything im doin away and put repeat on my player, turn off the lights and listen to some Pink Floyd ! ! -For those about to rock (we salute you)
0 @ 08-03-2007 12:17 StAmber
6 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal A Masterpiece. RIP Syd.
0 @ 14-03-2007 15:22 SleaterKinney
21 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal One of the best songs by one of the best bands of all time! And a worthy tribute to Syd! R.I.P
0 @ 24-03-2007 23:35 Jon10
7 posts	PF became PF as a better band without Syd B. Well, Syd was most into painting and stuff. The music he wanted the band to play was really strange. In the end the other bandmembers stop to call him, he was way off anyway. So its really without Syd B the band became PF as we all know PF. Syd B rest in peace. In the end, he was the founder of the band. Sorry, hardcore fans. Have you listen to the songs with Syd? Crazy stuff.
0 @ 15-05-2007 14:51 hofche
30 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal One of Pink Floyd's best, and by large their best album for my opinion.
0 @ 26-05-2007 18:58 too_sonia
1 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal
0 @ 10-07-2007 19:08 Famest
7 posts	As Jon10 said, crazy stuff, but heck, I love that crazy stuff, "apples&oranges" "see emily play" and Syd's best song ever, "Interstellar Overdrive"(which is said to be the best psychedelic song EVER made! Syd was amazing, and if he just would stop doing those drugs maybe he could be alive today (S)hine on (Y)ou crazy (D)iamond R.I.P Syd Barrett
0 @ 12-09-2007 19:18 instant3karma
1 posts	rhythm melody instruments lyrics vocal Syd was not actually kicked out of the band, he was asked to stay on as a songwriter but this proved too impractical. He left the band on rather good terms and was greatly respected by the rest of the band members, especially waters who wrote this song.... by the way one of the band's best songs ever!!! R.I.P Syd

Select page : [1] 2 next »

BROWSE:
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z Other

TOP ARTISTS:
Rihanna, Taylor Swift, Coldplay, Jason Mraz, Britney Spears, Jonas Brothers, Lil Wayne, Katy Perry, Miley Cyrus, Akon, T.I., Leona Lewis, Avril Lavigne, Ne-Yo, Pink, Paramore, Pussycat Dolls, The, Nickelback, Kanye West, Christina Aguilera, Chris Brown, Secondhand Serenade, Linkin Park, Jordin Sparks, Demi Lovato, Oasis, Metallica, Lady Gaga, Lifehouse, Beyonce, Eminem, Mariah Carey, Kings Of Leon, Evanescence, Slipknot, Camp Rock, Fall Out Boy, Avenged Sevenfold, Carrie Underwood, Celine Dion, Jack's Mannequin, Kelly Clarkson, Abba, M.I.A., Beatles, The, Colbie Caillat, Alicia Keys, Amy MacDonald, Danity Kane, Simple Plan

Artists / P / Pink Floyd / Songs / Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I-V) / Reviews

Pink Floyd - Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I-V) Reviews