| Song reviews |
|---|
 0  @ 16-05-2004 00:20 frossen_muffin |
1,757 posts
| Yeah, it's good. The original is better, but this one was interesting and different 
* offtopic :
Hey, you have 666 posts :p
|
| 0 @ 16-05-2004 03:19 guitargirl1234 |
33 posts
| i love that song. |
| 0 @ 29-07-2004 19:40 Mybrownlights |
9 posts
|
rhythm 
melody
instruments
lyrics 
vocal
great song. |
| 0 @ 29-07-2004 19:47 buttercup89 |
11,302 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
I like the original just a wee bit better, but this one is really great as well. He makes it into his own, and it's just really great. I love it. |
| 0 @ 08-08-2004 16:41 Pattygree |
23 posts
| really good  |
| 0 @ 08-08-2004 16:45 Lija |
85 posts
| WHAT how is this good it is shi'ite! if the gallaghers were dead they wud b turnin in their graves! its got nooooo character! |
| 0 @ 10-08-2004 11:58 Jimmy_Jazz |
19 posts
| Ya, this song sucked. Its so lame.  |
| 0 @ 10-08-2004 12:01 bikerbaby |
321 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
no i love this song!!!!! 
makes me happy *hums* |
| 0 @ 12-08-2004 13:09 onesk8erchic |
12 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
I love this song so much but its not like ill listen to it all the time i have better/other music to listen to |
| 0 @ 03-10-2004 21:02 Ploline |
16 posts
| To quote the person that said that "if the gallachers were dead they would be turning in their graves...."
I can only say that Noel Gallacher actually said that this was a brilliant version of this song and that it was one of the main reasons why decided to get back into the studio.... so i don't see much grave turning going on.
Anyway i love this song and I love Ryan Adams. So underrated yet soo bloody good.  |
| 0 @ 05-11-2004 15:39 rcs |
1,572 posts
| He tried. Really hard. Didn't work, though.  Oasis rules the Wonderwall. |
| 0 @ 08-11-2004 04:04 3x5comfwheel |
7,935 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
I heard this song on The O.C. It's a gorgeous song!  |
| 0 @ 08-11-2004 04:59 gimpfreak07 |
15 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
I really like this song. One of my friends sang it for our school battle of the bands. It is a really good song. |
| 0 @ 20-11-2004 02:04 3x5comfwheel |
7,935 posts
| I also heard this song on the O.C. I have a whole new respect for Ryan Adams now. |
| 0 @ 27-12-2004 16:24 honeey__ |
3 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
I love this song!  No one has done it better then ryan adams, and no one will! |
| 0 @ 02-01-2005 09:05 FairlyEllie |
21 posts
|
rhythm 
melody
instruments 
lyrics
vocal
What abotu Oasis? Oasis did the very first version of this song, and i think their brit-pop way about it is the best one. I dont think ive ever heard a sucessful cover of this song. This one is ok, but he has totally changed the melody, and has butchred it a bit too much for my liking |
| 0 @ 08-01-2005 07:58 stuckeybowler |
330 posts
| I like Ryan Adams, but he can't touch Oasis. This is not as good as the first one. |
| 0 @ 16-01-2005 18:20 cassidee |
8 posts
| This was a good change, the only reason I prolly liked it was cause of the OC, its pretty good, but the nothing can ever be as good as the original |
| 0 @ 26-01-2005 01:23 jules5488 |
17 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
ryan adam's version of this song has a very haunting, beautiful tone to it. but still, it can't beat the original. every time i listen to this version i always try to sing it like oasis did, cuz you just cant change an original like that. however, the song is still beautiful. |
| 0 @ 31-01-2005 10:45 nattyxoxo |
53 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
Nothing beats oasis, but Adams does this song exceptionally well! |
| 0 @ 09-03-2005 10:05 Bramblerose |
1,888 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
I like the rather melancholy feeling he has brought to this song. I love Oasis and the original version but this is not bad at all. It's different and I'm happy that he didn't just do another lame cover but instead made it sound like something new. |
| 0 @ 27-03-2005 21:24 JSouthy |
9 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
great cover. takes the song to a new level |
| 0 @ 20-08-2005 18:31 _crazee_ |
13 posts
| yeah, I thin kiuts a great cover
i love how.. Mellow it is |
| 0 @ 20-08-2005 19:05 hobbitongurl |
4,053 posts
| i think he totally butchered the song. it sounds horrible |
| 0 @ 28-08-2005 23:37 WOOOincubus |
128 posts
|
rhythm
melody
instruments
lyrics
vocal
I think Ryan Adams has given this song a lot more character.... dont get me wrong the original is really good but this version is far better... there's definatley far more emotion put into it by Ryan than there was in the original - far more...
An already good song turned superb ....  |
8.7